Revising an Argument with New Evidence
If new scientific studies challenge the claims made in an op-ed, which of the following describes the most responsible approach for the writer to take during revision?
A
Critically evaluating the new studies’ merits while determining how they might alter the argument’s premises or conclusions.
B
Immediately discrediting all previously cited studies without considering how they might still hold value.
C
Leaving the original argument intact, regardless of how compelling the new evidence may be.
D
Replacing older evidence with information from the latest study, ignoring possibly enduring validity of earlier work.
Question Leaderboard
Not enough data yet to show leaderboard.