Small Office Network Design
A small design firm is setting up a new office network to support 15 wired workstations, a local file server, and Wi-Fi access for employee laptops. The firm requires high-speed local file transfers between the workstations and the server, as well as the ability to configure VLANs in the future to separate guest Wi-Fi traffic from the internal network.
The firm is considering two approaches. Approach 1 uses a consumer all-in-one wireless router with a built-in 4-port switch, connected to two unmanaged 8-port switches to provide enough ports. Approach 2 uses a dedicated wired router connected to a single 24-port managed switch, with a standalone wireless access point connected to the switch.
Why is Approach 2 better suited to the firm’s stated requirements than Approach 1?
Approach 1 limits the local file server’s transfer speeds because unmanaged switches cannot forward traffic between wired workstations.
The managed switch in Approach 2 supports the creation of VLANs for future network separation, whereas the unmanaged switches in Approach 1 do not.
The standalone wireless access point in Approach 2 provides built-in network address translation (NAT) for guest traffic, which the all-in-one router lacks.
Approach 2 eliminates the need for a router by allowing the 24-port managed switch to connect directly to the ISP for internet access.
Question Leaderboard
Not enough data yet to show leaderboard.
