Comparing Stateful and Stateless VLAN Policies
A company network policy states: “Devices in the Finance VLAN (VLAN 40) must not initiate connections to the Development VLAN (VLAN 50). Devices in the Development VLAN may initiate connections to the Finance VLAN for specific database queries, and the return traffic must be permitted.” A network engineer is evaluating two approaches to implement this policy.
Approach A: Place a stateless Access Control List (ACL) on the router that denies all traffic originating from VLAN 40 destined for VLAN 50, and permits all traffic originating from VLAN 50 destined for VLAN 40.
Approach B: Deploy a stateful firewall between the VLANs configured to allow new sessions from VLAN 50 to VLAN 40, and drop new sessions from VLAN 40 to VLAN 50.
How do these two approaches compare in satisfying the stated access policy?
Approach B satisfies the policy because the stateful firewall will automatically permit the required return traffic to VLAN 50, whereas Approach A will block the return traffic from VLAN 40.
Approach A satisfies the policy because stateless ACLs automatically track connection states, whereas Approach B requires manual rules for return traffic.
Both approaches fail because neither explicitly mentions allowing broadcast traffic between the two VLANs, which is required for database queries.
Both approaches succeed equally because both prevent VLAN 40 from initiating connections while allowing VLAN 50 to send database queries.
Question Leaderboard
Not enough data yet to show leaderboard.
