Comparing Edge Redundancy Designs
A financial services firm is evaluating two redundant network designs to connect its main office to a cloud provider.
Design X uses a single edge router at the main office connected to two different internet service providers (ISPs).
Design Y uses two separate edge routers at the main office, both connected to a single ISP.
The firm wants to protect against two specific failure cases: a hardware failure of an edge router, and a widespread routing outage within an ISP’s core network.
How do the two designs compare when evaluated against the stated failure cases?
Both designs provide equal protection against an edge router failure, but only Design X protects against an ISP routing outage.
Design X protects against both an edge router failure and an ISP routing outage, while Design Y only protects against an edge router failure.
Design X protects against an ISP routing outage but fails if the edge router breaks, while Design Y protects against an edge router failure but fails during an ISP routing outage.
Design Y protects against an ISP routing outage but fails if an edge router breaks, while Design X protects against an edge router failure but fails during an ISP routing outage.
Question Leaderboard
Not enough data yet to show leaderboard.
