Diagnostic Approaches and the TCP/IP Model
A network administrator is troubleshooting a user’s inability to access an internal web application. The administrator considers two diagnostic approaches.
Approach 1: Use the ping command to send ICMP Echo Requests to the web server’s IP address.
Approach 2: Use a utility to attempt a TCP handshake with the web server’s IP address on port 443.
The web server is located behind a stateful firewall that permits TCP port 443 traffic but explicitly drops all ICMP traffic for security reasons.
How do these two approaches compare in isolating the fault within the TCP/IP model under the stated conditions?
Approach 2 successfully verifies Transport layer connectivity, whereas Approach 1 will falsely suggest an Internet layer failure due to the firewall’s ICMP rule.
Approach 1 successfully verifies Transport layer connectivity, whereas Approach 2 will falsely suggest an Application layer failure.
Both approaches will fail because the firewall drops ICMP traffic, preventing the necessary Transport layer handshake from completing.
Approach 1 verifies Application layer functionality, whereas Approach 2 only verifies Internet layer routing.
Question Leaderboard
Not enough data yet to show leaderboard.
