Evaluating IDS and IPS Deployments
A hospital network administrator is evaluating how to deploy a new security appliance to monitor traffic between the guest Wi-Fi network and the internet. The hospital has recently seen an increase in new malware signatures originating from guest devices.
The administrator is considering two approaches: deploying the appliance as an Intrusion Detection System (IDS) connected to a switch mirror port, or deploying it as an Intrusion Prevention System (IPS) placed directly inline between the guest network switch and the perimeter firewall.
Which of the following accurately compares the capabilities and limits of these two approaches under the stated conditions?
The inline IPS will decrypt all guest traffic without requiring certificates, while the mirror-port IDS requires the administrator to manually inspect encrypted payloads.
The mirror-port IDS guarantees that no malicious traffic will reach the internet, but it introduces significant latency to the guest network’s connection.
The inline IPS can automatically block malicious traffic before it reaches the firewall, but a hardware failure of the IPS appliance could disrupt all guest internet access.
The mirror-port IDS can actively drop malicious packets by modifying the switch’s routing table, whereas the IPS can only log the events for later review.
Question Leaderboard
Not enough data yet to show leaderboard.
