Evaluating Redundant Circuit Designs
A junior network administrator is tasked with designing a redundant connection between a branch office and the headquarters. The administrator proposes the following design: “We will lease two separate physical circuits from the same Internet Service Provider (ISP). Both circuits will terminate on the same edge router at the branch office. Because we have two circuits, our branch office is fully protected against any single point of failure connecting us to headquarters.”
Which of the following best diagnoses the error in the junior administrator’s reasoning regarding the stated failure cases?
The design fails to realize that leasing two circuits from the same ISP provides less bandwidth than a single circuit due to overhead from redundancy protocols.
The design is flawed because two circuits from the same ISP will automatically cancel each other out, resulting in a routing loop that brings down the network.
The design fails to account for the edge router itself being a single point of failure, and using the same ISP may expose the branch to a single provider-wide outage.
The design incorrectly assumes that redundant circuits must terminate on the same router; terminating them on different routers would violate standard routing protocols.
Question Leaderboard
Not enough data yet to show leaderboard.
