Troubleshooting Inter-VLAN Connectivity
A network uses a Layer 3 switch to route traffic between VLAN 10 (Sales) and VLAN 20 (Engineering). A Sales user reports they cannot connect to the Engineering file server.
A packet capture taken on the Sales user’s access switchport shows the user’s workstation repeatedly broadcasting ARP requests for the Engineering server’s IP address. No replies are received.
Admin X proposes checking the user’s local IPv4 configuration (subnet mask and default gateway). Admin Y proposes checking the Layer 3 switch to ensure it is configured to forward broadcast traffic between VLAN 10 and VLAN 20.
Which administrator’s approach is correct based on the packet capture evidence and standard routing principles?
Admin X, because ARP requests are only used to resolve MAC addresses to IP addresses, indicating a DNS failure on the workstation.
Admin Y, because the lack of an ARP reply proves the trunk link between the access switch and the Layer 3 switch is down.
Admin X, because the workstation should be sending ARP requests for its default gateway’s MAC address, not the remote server’s IP address.
Admin Y, because inter-VLAN routing requires the Layer 3 switch to forward ARP broadcasts so the remote server can reply directly.
Question Leaderboard
Not enough data yet to show leaderboard.
